An Omani Girl Unveils Stereotypes of Omani Life & History
"Oh my Ggoddd..." Kay cringed as the bats skittered up above. Bahla Fort is home to a colony of bats, which nest in the alcoves of the dim, cave-like fortress rooms.
We had just walked into one such room, and the motion disturbed the bats enough that they began moving from one rafter to another, sending out high-pitched vocalisations.
"What?" I asked absently, looking around to what the young engineer was shrinking from. "Oh!" I exclaimed, with a little laugh. "They're not gonna do anything! They just-"
Kay bit down a scream, as a bat flew a little too low for comfort. "-all you have to do is stay still," I continued, smiling. "They need to make the sounds, so that when the sound reflects back, they know where you are, and then they can avoid you."
"Oh my God." Kay muttered miserably in a small voice, but she rallied. Another bat fluttered across. "See? Oh my God... I'm so scared." But her voice grew stronger. We passed into another room.
- An Unlikely Tour Guide of Omani History
- Oman: at the threshold of transition
- Overcoming Stereotypes about Omani Life
- Carbon offsetting information to Oman
An Unlikely Tour Guide of Omani History
"So also..." Kay's voice recovered instantly, picking up where she had left off before being surprised by the bats. It was so funny. She forgot her fear once she was engrossed again in delivering the history lesson.
I wasn't sure where Chian and Em had gone by this point. But I didn't mind. We didn't have a tour guide at Bahla Fort, but that's not necessarily a problem if you're travelling with young female engineers. Generally this demographic would have had to do well in school in order to get hired as corporate engineers in the first place, and probably had paid attention.
It turned out to be the case that day. Kay still remembered all of her Omani history.
Clan history of Oman
Bahla Fort dated from the era before Oman was unified. The region received repeated invaders ("the Persians invaded Oman sooo many times!"), and sometimes the clans also warred against each other. Hence the necessity for defensive fortifications.
Eventually, the clans of the region began electing a primus inter pare, a leader among equals - an Imam. Thus began the Imamate era of Oman, during which the clans were loosely unified under a kind of federation.
"The clans are like different states," continued Kay in her Arab-accented English. "But the Imam, he is like the ruler of all of them. OK, but they were like, independent." Like Scotland, my mind prompted, ever finding parallels in patterns.
"Like, Sharqiyah has their own ruler," she explained, citing her own clan whose territory was the dry desert where Chian had taken me on a previous visit. "And here, in Bahla they have the Imam."
There was already a sultan in Muscat at the time, she said, but back then the sultan in Muscat did not rule all of Oman. Well, he was sultan of all Oman, but each region was independent.
This seeming contradiction would have confused me, except that I'd already read a lot of medieval history as a teenager, and it reminded me of the mostly voluntary allegiance of powerful European dukes to the royal kings.
The Omani empire
"And then the Sultan wanted to unite everything under his rule, so then there was some sort of war between the Imams and the Sultan, and then the Sultan won, and khalas," she concluded.
Then, remembering an important omission, she added, "But before that it was against the Portuguese. They invaded Muscat - all the coastal areas. So there were wars with the Portuguese, and at the furthest point, they went all the way to India."
"Really??" I exclaimed. I did not know this about Omani history. "Oman fought all the way to India?"
Kay assented. "Oman followed the Portuguese to India and then kicked them out of these coasts. At that time Oman ruled a place in Pakistan called Baluchistan."
"Ah yeah?" I wondered whether the Balushi clan in Oman that Chian mentioned, were originally from this part of the old empire. My mind was blown by all the colonial-era history that I did not know. I had assumed that Oman was just a low-profile fishing coast before modern statehood.
"Bahrain, Zanzibar, Tanzania, these places were all under the Oman sultan," she continued. "They moved the capital of Oman to Zanzibar at one time. Muscat was too poor. Zanzibar was the second biggest point of Oman then, after Muscat."
What. Zanzibar was on my bucket list, but I hadn't really thought of it as being part of an empire, let alone an Arab one. Let alone the capital of said empire!
The dark side of empire
"How did they lose Zanzibar??" A rich capital city - how did they lose it?
Kay paused in her enthusiastic description of glorious Zanzibar, the houses and castles there still owned by the lineage of Omani sultans. "Because then they had a war with the British. Then they had their independence, and they killed most of the Omanis there. The rest came back to Oman."
I noted the change in the use of 'they' and 'Oman'. Zanzibar became 'they', and 'Oman' no longer included it.
There was a shadow there. Independence comes with massacre, typically when there has been oppression.
I later learned that Zanzibar had initially invited Omanis to liberate them from the Portuguese, and even encouraged settlement of Omani princes to the island.
However, as a key trading port in the Indian Ocean, Zanzibar also traded in slaves. The slave trade* grew to be increasingly lucrative, and the sultan of Zanzibar relied on it for funds to secure his power. Zanzibar switched from merely profiting from the slave trade, to directly engaging in it.
But the tide of the world was finally turning on slavery, and the Sultan of Zanzibar proved to be too late to the game.
Then & Now: Omani Life in Zanzibar
You'd think that, following such a history, there would be animosity today between Zanzibar and Oman. Or even, between Oman and Great Britain.
But apparently, there are still Omanis living in Zanzibar. Omanis still have family in Zanzibar, they marry in Zanzibar. Kay's own family still have farms and a manor house there. Omanis still own Stone Town's UNESCO Heritage castles and gardens; the Omani government still funds their maintenance as the Tanzanian government cannot afford it. Zanzibar's economy is reliant on trade with Oman, and the Omani government still sends financial assistance to Zanzibar.
And Great Britain seems to me to be the European nation with the closest relationship with Oman today - treating each other as peers.
There is a lesson in there, somewhere.
"You know, I really recommend you read a book called The Diaries of the Omani Princess**. She was one of the sultan's daughters, who just ran away and married a German guy, and she settled in Germany," said Kay. The book she wrote described in amazing detail what castle life was like, how members of the royal family lived, and Zanzibar itself, when it was part of Oman.
Oman: at the threshold of transition
Oman was the first Middle Eastern country I visited. While I did not have bigoted stereotypes about Arabs (the trading history of the Malay archipelago meant that we already met Arabs and were exposed to Arab culture prior to European influence), I still had some preconceptions about Omani life. One of them was that Oman would be monoracial.
But it was not so.
I'm not talking about foreign workers. Chian told me that two of the major clans in Oman, the Al Lawati and the Al Balushi, originated from India.
In Muscat I saw local people who were not Arab - dressed as Omanis, speaking and behaving as Omanis. Some of them were darker than the majority fair-skinned Arabs. And a few were black Africans. They were together in public spaces. I even met an Omani officer of obvious African ethnicity when I was in a workshop with the Ministry of Environment.
You can't heal with an all-or-nothing mindset
I reflect back on that conversation in Bahla. On Kay's voice, nearly bursting with pride as she described how, during Omani rule, Zanzibar was founded from nothing, and became a city with electricity and roads and public services.
She knows that black people of Tanzania and Zanzibar won their freedom, which meant they had wanted to be. There was no animosity over that. But at the same time, the era had been a glorious one for Oman.
The present is accepted as if it should be. And the past is also accepted as something that had been, and had to have been.
And I understand that. I understand it in the same way as the British former colonies understand from consuming English literature, the pride that British people still want to have of their colonial era, even though we were the colonised. I can extrapolate that feeling to understand why white Southerners in the USA still want to take pride in Confederate era history, sans the slavery.
There were things of value to their identity that was formed then, even if the era was tainted by severe injustice. And I do believe you can carve out those things and keep a pride in them, without approving the evil that had been done.
Collateral beauty in a scene of Omani life
A thin old man was by the side of the road, as we drove out of Bahla. His skin darkened by long hours in the sun, he too was moving onward at a reasonable clip, headed to Friday prayers in a motorised wheelchair.
It was an incongruent scene of Omani life, for the dry rocky landscape surrounded us, and in the background were traditional pockets of hamlets that seemed to be from out of time. An old Omani man, made frail by age and life. A modern wheelchair, clearly well capable of traversing the gravelly rubble of the road shoulder, making it possible for him to keep the things that matter.
It brought to mind a lesser-known Will Smith movie I watched on a plane, perhaps on this very trip. It was called 'Collateral Beauty'. I don't remember the story very well, so it was probably mediocre. But its name and the concept it carries stuck with me, and made the movie itself irrelevant.
It is the opposite of collateral damage, where you tolerate necessary damage for the sake of a desirable outcome. Rather, collateral beauty are the achingly beautiful things that can only exist in the wake of tragic events.
There is collateral beauty all around, ready to help the healing whenever you are. But you can't see it until you stop living within the damage.
The succession dilemma of Sultan Qaboos
In the car, I asked the girls about the political situation. Sultan Qaboos was a beloved monarch, credited for uniting and modernising Oman. But he was ailing, and many speculated whether he was at death's door.
It was worrisome. Omani life is peaceful, astonishingly safe and orderly. I felt far safer in Oman than in Europe. It was surprisingly courteous and laidback, its people not giving off uptight vibes in the least.
But Oman is surrounded by less stable neighbours. ROP is always catching Saudi spies in Oman, the girls claimed, referring to the Royal Omani Police who served as police, counter-terrorism, and border security all in one. How long could the Qaboos peace last after him? I wondered what the plan was.
"His family has to agree who becomes sultan after him, because he died without children," said Kay. Apparently, if they couldn't agree, the sultan had left his recommendation in a sealed envelope, to be opened only in this event.
Epilogue on the succession
At the time, I was sceptical that the vying princes would respect the recommendation of a dead man. On top of that, neighbouring Saudi had seen a dramatic coup by MBS, which saw him remove all possible contenders from posing any threat to his absolute authority.
I wondered if the Omani royal house could possibly be much more civilised, and really simply agree among them on who would take power. You know, instead of fighting it out?
But at the time of writing, Sultan Qaboos has passed from this world. And his family did indeed agree on a successor.
Overcoming Stereotypes about Omani Life
One of my regrets about my early business travel, was that I didn't make time to have personal days around the trip. Had I done so, perhaps I might have learned more about Omani life and people, and by now understood even more. I don't mean just about Oman either, but many adjacent things.
I had many stereotypes, even without a negative perception of Oman. Most were assumed based off of the higher profile nations in the region. But Oman was not like these things that I had in my subconscious. Or rather, sometimes they were, but not always in the way I thought I understood.
Even little things about Omani life, like 'Arab food involves a lot of dairy'. Omani/Gulf food is actually low on dairy, unlike cuisine close to the Mediterranean. Some Omanis are even lactose intolerant. They do take camel milk, but they only drink it freshly milked.
Oh, and that Omanis are into dance music, which they dance to at weddings. I'd not have guessed that genre at all!
You learn a heck of a lot when you chat with women!
The power of negative stereotypes
I was once harangued by a Tongan man in Vava'u, who had picked up anti-Arab bigotry from his time working in Australia. Why do Muslims make their women walk behind them? He kept pressing me on the question, but it's not a Southeast Asian thing at all. It's one of those 'why do you beat your wife' questions, which are impossible to answer.
Being me, I was more interested in philosophically wondering why we even assign a higher value to 'the front' than 'the back'. Or, is it assumed as such purely because that's where the man is (supposedly), which then creates a circular logic that also cannot be resolved?
But anyway it's not even true in Oman. I wish I'd remembered then, that I had this rebuttal on my phone.
The litmus test
Another time, I quarrelled with a friend over something, and told him that for all his world travel, he only ever managed to meet the same type of people. This offended him a great deal, so I threw in a litmus test. I sent him a photo of a frankincense candle that I had bought in Oman for a colleague. I told him it was frankincense, that the place is famous for it, and told him to guess.
Right, so I didn't really expect him to guess Oman. But if he were only marginally world-wise, he would get at least the region right. It was not really a difficult test at all. He is technically Greek Orthodox after all, from a heavily American-influenced culture, and should remember better than I that the three wise men came to Bethlehem from the East, with nativity scenes usually showing them on camels. They came bearing gold, frankincense, and myrrh.
He guessed 'Israel'. Nope. Then, instead of correcting eastwards, he went west, into Europe, even guessing into Scandinavia! Still unsuccessful, he panicked, and went halfway around the world, guessing 'Brazil'. Still no. Truly grasping at straws by this time, he went into Asia, completely skipping over the Middle East.
When you close your eyes, you cannot see what's right in front of you
I finally told him where I got it from, because it was getting ridiculous. I mean, I was pleased to be right, but I didn't want to be that right.
And it was obvious to him, once he heard the answer.
But he couldn't see it at the outset, because the narrative of modern Western culture had trained him not to.
Not to see the Middle East in its complexities, contradictions, surprises, and humanity. Not to see them as being just like us.
*It may be difficult for us to appreciate what the world was like in pre-modern times, since the default of being born free is all we know. However, history and ancient literature buffs will realise that, for much of human civilisation, it was special to be 'freemen'. At any time your nation could be successfully invaded, and if you survive, it is to be a slave.
Today, you might end up a refugee, or stateless, or exploited. It is still possible to fall into slave-like conditions. But you will know that this isn't normal. Before the 19th century's effort for universal abolition, the worldview was the other way around. Slaves considered it part of the normal, lamentable fate of the world. It was freedom that was special. You can't fully appreciate a whole lot of old literature, if you can't imagine this context.
In a way, this drove militarisation of nations. After all, the best way to ensure your own people didn't become slaves, is if you enslaved the threatening nations first.
Additionally, during this time, slavery was not like what is understood from the American context. You got enslaved mainly because your leaders could not defend your freedom. All races faced this same risk, in theory. There was not an overarching philosophy to say that a certain race should inherently not enslave their own, or that a certain other race was genetically 'meant to be' slaves. Slavery before European imperialism was a sin of cruelty, not of racism. Thankfully when the Europeans repented, they tore down the whole thing.
**The book's title is Memoirs of an Arabian Princess. I am usually wary about blatantly orientalist books in English, especially if the writer seemed like they abandoned their culture for a Western one. The reason is that these books do well in Western lists of literary merit in the first place, typically because they play on stereotypes that Westerners want to hear about Eastern peoples; they wouldn't have become bestsellers otherwise.
How close would these books be to narratives the people of the culture would tell to themselves? I have no way of knowing. There's nothing wrong in looking for niche or contrary points of view, per se. But personally, what I'm looking for is to understand the broad culture, how a people see themselves. An unrepresentative, highly individual point of view doesn't do that.
However, in this case, an Omani young woman from a thoroughly mainstream background and respectable clan has endorsed it, so I feel comfortable passing on the recommendation.
This is the kind of article that you might want to re-read and think about. Why not pin it?
Carbon offsetting information to Oman
A return flight between Kuala Lumpur and Muscat produces carbon emissions of approximately 4,184 lbs CO2e. It costs about $21 to offset this.